Why We Need More Second Chances

/By  Jarrell Allen
My incarceration did not just impact me. When I went to prison, my family suffered because of my absence, too: as the oldest of five children, I’d helped with everything from an early age.

April is Second Chance Month – and I believe people have a right to a second chance, and to redeem themselves of their worst wrongdoings. I am grateful for my own second chance and know that so many other people who are still incarcerated deserve a second chance, too. My story of a second chance was made possible because of the work to change outdated sentencing laws, and I know we need more commonsense changes that help others make amends and rejoin their families – healing entire communities in the process.

At age seventeen, I was given a life sentence. And after serving 33 years in prison, on December 23, 2020, D.C.’s Second Look law enabled me to come home. I’m very remorseful about what I did, and hardly a day goes by that I don’t feel ashamed of my past actions. But while I can’t undo what I’ve done, I can be better – and millions of other people like me deserve a second chance to come home to their families and communities, too.

While in federal custody, I was shuffled across the country to different prisons, hundreds and sometimes even thousands of miles from my family. The conditions in those prisons were deplorable and made me feel excluded from society. Often, when I was transferred, my property would be damaged or destroyed. But I tried to make the best of it – I began work in the kitchen for 12 cents an hour, and went to school, taking a GED class, and I read books and newspapers to feel normal – like I was still a part of society.

I was 19 years old in 1989 when I earned my GED, and it felt like such an accomplishment that I wanted to continue my education. Even though I had earned my GED, I was prohibited from enrolling to attend college in other penitentiaries, until I was moved to Wisconsin Baraboo. But as soon as I was able, I applied for a Pell Grant and began college. Unfortunately, not long after I enrolled, Pell Grant eligibility was taken away from incarcerated people – that chance at covering the cost of further education was gone. I was crushed – I’d fought so hard, only to have another opportunity snatched away. But I continued to participate in any programs I could while incarcerated, including acquiring trades such as upholstery and HVAC. I poured myself into my grief and loss group and victim impact classes, which eventually led to me mentoring others and moving into a cognitive behavior therapy unit called The Challenge Program, where I became a mental health companion and senior peer mentor.

My incarceration did not just impact me. When I went to prison, my family suffered because of my absence, too: as the oldest of five children, I’d helped with everything from an early age. Now, my mother no longer had me to lean on, and my sisters and brothers began to act out. My going to prison accelerated the destruction of my community, and my actions splintered three families. When my mother struggled with substance use, my siblings had to go live with my aunt in New York. And my entire extended family suffered financially. My family did the best they could to support me by adding money to my commissary account when they could and trying to make sure I could talk to my siblings around the holidays.

Mass incarceration has destroyed so many communities across the nation; it perpetuates enormous psychological damage to entire families and communities that can’t be undone.

For families that don’t have much by way of finances, spending thousands of dollars to fly across the country, or even to pay for collect phone calls, isn’t feasible – in my case, this meant that the only time I received visits was when I was incarcerated very close to home. The costs of having a family member incarcerated for extended periods of time is a huge financial burden – and communities and the overall economy suffer, as well. Mass incarceration has destroyed so many communities across the nation; it perpetuates enormous psychological damage to entire families and communities that can’t be undone.

I believe strongly in the power of redemption because of the healing and forgiveness process I experienced from my victim’s mother. While I was incarcerated, we exchanged letters, and she forgave me and trusted that I felt truly remorseful in my heart. She had compassion for me when she didn’t have to: so I honor her belief in me by continuing to be better and making thoughtful decisions. And her belief in me has fueled my own compassion for others. I began to forgive myself when I started to be proud of the growth I saw in myself. Over time, my hope returned and grew strong. I finally felt and believed in humanity. I want other people who are incarcerated to develop this belief in themselves, too – these men, women, and children who are incarcerated deserve a second chance, because no one should be defined by and judged for their entire life by their worst choice.

I am a man whose strongest attributes are compassion, humility, and clear-eyed objectivity about my experiences. When I was younger, I never thought about what I could give to my community, or what they meant to me or how they perceived me. At 50, I now know who I am, and I always want to be part of the solution. I am a Poet Ambassador at Free Minds book club, traveling around speaking with others and mentoring youth. I work with juvenile justice groups such as Campaign for Fair Sentencing of Youth and Changing Perceptions. Currently, I’m a BreakFree Education fellow, which has given me the opportunity to work at FWD.us. I’m excited to work in criminal justice reform advocacy and use my lived experiences to help more people have a second chance.

As Second Chance month comes to a close, I hope we can refocus on the proven solutions that truly make our communities safer, bringing more people home to their loved ones, and helping support them as they make their way back.

Since I’ve been home, I’ve been able to continue to strengthen my relationships with my family and really be present for them. When I’m spending time with my sisters, nieces, and nephews talking, laughing, or cooking, those are the best times in my life. Just hearing the words “Uncle Peanut” means the world to me, because they mean the world to me. That’s a responsibility for me that I welcome, and they know they can count on me.

The criminal justice system itself does not rehabilitate people – it compounds the trauma and pain of communities that are already hurting, and of many people who never had a first chance to begin with. I was released from prison after serving 33 years, and I’m deeply grateful for my second chance – but I don’t want others to suffer in the same way, or for so long, before they have a shot at their own second chance. As Second Chance month comes to a close, I hope we can refocus on the proven solutions that truly make our communities safer, bringing more people home to their loved ones, and helping support them as they make their way back.

Tell the world; share this article via...